Topological phase

Everyday term

In plain words

A state of matter told apart not by how its atoms are arranged but by a whole number that describes how its electrons’ waves twist across the crystal – the way a doughnut differs from a ball by its one hole. A whole number cannot change a little, so what it guarantees, such as current running along an edge without loss, survives defects and dirt until the itself closes.

Going deeper

Left: three outlines – a ball with no hole, a ring with one hole and a figure-eight shape with two – labelled 0, 1 and 2, noting that the count cannot change without tearing. Right: a rectangular sheet shaded as insulating inside, with arrows running around its edge labelled edge channel, and a note that where the whole number changes, at the edge, the gap has to close. counting what cannot change smoothly 0 holes 1 hole 2 holes no smooth deformation changes the count; a topological phase has such a count in the way its electrons’ waves twist a topological sheet insulating inside the gap stays open the edge conducts: here the count drops to the vacuum’s zero, so the gap closes what the count protects survives dirt and defects until the gap itself closes
Left: topology counts features that smooth deformation cannot change, such as the number of holes. Right: in a topological phase the count is a property of the electrons’ bands, and at the edge of the sheet, where it drops to the vacuum’s zero, the gap has to close – so the edge conducts while the inside insulates.

Counting holes, counting twists

Topology is the part of geometry that ignores stretching and bending: a mug and a doughnut count as the same shape because each has one hole, and no smooth deformation can add or remove one. In the early 1980s physicists found the same kind of whole number in the electronic states of crystals. Add up how the electrons’ waves twist as their momentum runs across the whole Brillouin zone and the total is always an integer, however the crystal is distorted, as long as the band gap stays open.

The first example was the . Thouless and colleagues showed in 1982 that the integer is the Hall conductance measured in units of e2/h, which is why that conductance is quantised to better than a part in a billion in real, dirty samples – the number simply has nowhere to go. The 2016 Nobel Prize in Physics went to Thouless, Haldane and for bringing topology into the physics of matter.

Why a whole number protects things

A number that can only be 0, 1, 2 … cannot drift with temperature or ; it can only jump, and a jump requires the band gap to close. A topological property is therefore robust against everything that leaves the gap open. The flip side is the most useful consequence. Vacuum has invariant zero, so at the edge of a the number has to change, the gap has to close there, and conducting states are forced to exist along the boundary even though the interior insulates. This bulk–boundary correspondence is what gives topological insulators their edge and .

Some invariants exist only while a symmetry holds. The Z2 index of a topological insulator relies on , which is why magnetism opens a gap in its surface states, and crystalline topological phases rely on mirrors or rotations. A needs no symmetry at all. “Topological defects” – vortices, , domain walls – use the same mathematics for a different object: a knot in an rather than in the .

Topology in 2D materials, and claims to check

Two-dimensional materials are where several of these phases were first seen or are now cleanest. The quantum anomalous Hall effect – quantised Hall conductance with no magnetic field – appeared first in magnetic topological-insulator films in 2013 and later in of MnBi2Te4; WTe2 shows quantum spin Hall up to about 100 K; and twisted MoTe2 and graphene on hBN host , the zero-field cousins of fractional quantum Hall states.

The word is also used loosely, so claims deserve checking. A calculated invariant is a prediction whose gap may be smaller than the error of the method. Surface states seen in can be trivial – -split or states look similar. The strong evidence is a quantised transport value, backed by non-local transport or imaging that shows the current running along the edges rather than through the bulk.

For specialists

A gapped phase characterised by a topological invariant of its occupied bands – a Chern number, a Z2 index, a winding number – that cannot change under deformations that keep the gap open and any protecting symmetry intact. Where regions with different invariants meet, the gap must close, which forces boundary states: chiral edge channels in Chern insulators, helical ones in quantum spin Hall insulators, in Weyl semimetals, in topological . Topological order in the strict sense – the long-range entanglement of fractional quantum Hall states and – is a distinct, stronger notion.

Where this comes from

  1. Quantized Hall conductance in a two-dimensional periodic potential Thouless et al. · Physical Review Letters 49, 405 (1982) cited by 6,954
  2. Colloquium: topological insulators Hasan and Kane · Reviews of Modern Physics 82, 3045 (2010) cited by 19,966