Ferromagnet and antiferromagnet

Everyday term

In plain words

In a ferromagnet the tiny magnets of the atoms all point the same way, as in a fridge magnet. In an antiferromagnet neighbours point in opposite directions and cancel out. Both kinds of order have been found in sheets only one layer thick.

Going deeper

Left: a row of arrows all pointing up for a ferromagnet with a net moment; a row alternating up and down for an antiferromagnet whose moments cancel; and a side view of two layers, one all up and one all down, for a layered antiferromagnet such as bilayer CrI₃. Right: spin-wave energy against wavevector. A dashed curve for an isotropic magnet starts at zero energy; a solid curve with easy-axis anisotropy starts above zero, offset by a gap Δ, which lets order survive in two dimensions. how neighbouring moments line up ferromagnet all parallel: a net moment antiferromagnet alternating: moments cancel layered antiferromagnet, side view each layer ferromagnetic, layers opposed (bilayer CrI₃) why anisotropy lets 2D order survive spin-wave energy wavevector Δ with easy-axis anisotropy, a gap Δ: order survives isotropic: no gap
Ferromagnets align neighbouring moments, antiferromagnets alternate them, and layered antiferromagnets such as bilayer CrI3 do both – parallel within each layer, opposed between layers. In a single layer, order survives only if anisotropy opens a gap in the spin-wave spectrum.

Why neighbouring moments line up

Magnetic moments come mostly from unpaired . What aligns them is not the weak magnetic force between them but exchange, a quantum-mechanical effect of the Pauli principle and electrostatic repulsion. Depending on the orbitals and bonds involved, exchange favours parallel neighbours, giving a ferromagnet, or antiparallel ones, giving an antiferromagnet; if the opposing moments are unequal, the result is a ferrimagnet.

In magnetic such as CrI3 the coupling runs through the ligands between the metal atoms. Cr–I–Cr bonds close to 90° favour ferromagnetic alignment, a case covered by the Goodenough–Kanamori rules. Order sets in below the for a ferromagnet and the Néel temperature for an antiferromagnet, above which thermal agitation wins.

Magnetism in a single layer

The forbids long-range order at any finite temperature in a two-dimensional magnet whose spins can point equally well in any direction: of arbitrarily low energy are always excited and destroy it. – a preferred axis – gives those spin waves a minimum energy, and order survives.

CrI3, with a strong out-of-plane easy axis, is ferromagnetic below about 45 K. Cr2Ge2Te6, with much weaker anisotropy, loses order quickly as it is thinned, and its thinnest layers needed a small magnetic field to stabilise it. Other layered magnets cover the rest of the range: Fe3GeTe2 is a metallic ferromagnet, CrSBr an antiferromagnet with an in-plane easy axis, and FePS3 an antiferromagnet whose order persists down to the monolayer.

Layered antiferromagnets and how they are measured

In thin CrI3, each layer is ferromagnetic but neighbouring layers point opposite ways, so a bilayer has no net moment. A magnetic field flips layers one by one, and tunnelling currents through such a stack change by very large factors as it does. can switch the magnetic state electrically. Bulk CrI3, by contrast, couples its layers ferromagnetically, a difference linked to how the layers stack in thin .

A single flake holds far too few moments for ordinary , so magnetism is detected optically through the Kerr effect or magnetic , with nitrogen-vacancy magnetometry, or through transport. Antiferromagnets without a net moment are harder still and rely on scattering, or on bulk crystals. Many of these magnets degrade in air and are handled in and sealed in hBN.

For specialists

Magnetically ordered states with parallel (ferromagnetic) or antiparallel (antiferromagnetic) alignment of neighbouring moments. Long-range order in 2D requires to evade the Mermin–Wagner theorem; CrI3 monolayers are Ising-like ferromagnets that couple antiferromagnetically between layers, and the MPS3 compounds are antiferromagnets.

Where this comes from

  1. Discovery of intrinsic ferromagnetism in two-dimensional van der Waals crystals Gong et al. · Nature 546, 265 (2017) cited by 5,100
  2. Layer-dependent ferromagnetism in a van der Waals crystal down to the monolayer limit Huang et al. · Nature 546, 270 (2017) cited by 5,987