In plain words

The base a thin film or sits on – often a polished slice of silicon, glass or sapphire. For a crystal one atom thick, the substrate is not just a table: its bumps, stray charges and vibrations reach right into the sheet and change how it conducts and glows. That is why the same material can behave differently on two substrates, and why the flattest, cleanest one – boron nitride – gives the best results.

Going deeper

Three panels. On silicon dioxide: a sheet following every bump of a rough oxide surface, with positive and negative charges trapped in the oxide; electrons scatter. On boron nitride: the same sheet lying flat on a stack of flat boron nitride layers; electrons move freely. Grown on sapphire: a sapphire surface seen from above, with small triangular crystals all pointing the same way. on silicon dioxide the sheet follows every bump + − + rough, with charge trapped in the oxide electrons scatter on boron nitride flat, clean, no loose bonds a layered insulator with no dangling bonds electrons move freely grown on sapphire seen from above the surface turns every crystal the same way fewer seams where they meet
A monolayer feels everything beneath it. A rough, charged oxide scatters its electrons, flat boron nitride leaves them alone, and a growth substrate such as sapphire can even decide which way each crystal points.

What a substrate does to a sheet

For years the standard substrate was a silicon with a thin layer of silicon dioxide on top, chosen because a of graphene becomes visible on it under a microscope. It is a poor partner otherwise. Its surface is rough on the scale of atoms, and the sheet follows every bump. Charges trapped in the oxide break the sheet into puddles of extra . And vibrations of the oxide’s surface scatter electrons in the sheet even at room temperature.

The substrate also screens. Charges in the sheet are partly shielded by the material below, so a substrate with a high weakens the binding of and shrinks the . Swapping the substrate is therefore enough to shift a monolayer’s emission, and part of the scatter between published values comes from exactly this.

Why boron nitride became the standard

Hexagonal boron nitride is a layered with the same as graphene and a lattice only about 2 percent larger. Its cleaved surface is atomically flat, has no and holds very few trapped charges. In 2010 graphene placed on it showed and uniformity close to ten times better than on silicon dioxide, and since then boron nitride has been the default substrate and cover layer for high-quality 2D devices.

It also lets a substrate do something new. When graphene is laid on boron nitride with their lattices almost aligned, the small mismatch produces a that the electrons feel, and the substrate itself changes the material’s .

Grown on one, used on another

The substrate a layer grows on is rarely the one it ends up used on. Graphene grows best on copper foil, which dissolves very little carbon and so stops at one layer. grow as aligned triangles on sapphire, whose surface steers each crystal to the same orientation so that neighbouring crystals merge with few seams. The layer is then lifted off and , which can leave wrinkles, cracks and polymer residue.

For chip-making the aim is to grow on the final wafer directly, but a finished silicon chip tolerates only about 400 °C, far below the temperatures most 2D growth needs – which is why the , rather than the chemistry, often decides where a 2D layer can go.

For specialists

The material beneath a 2D layer. It acts on the layer through surface roughness, charged impurities, surface optical , dielectric screening, and , and during growth it sets orientation through . Replacing SiO2 with hexagonal boron nitride, which is atomically flat and nearly free of dangling bonds and charge traps, improved the mobility and charge homogeneity of graphene by close to an order of magnitude.

Where this comes from

  1. Boron nitride substrates for high-quality graphene electronics Dean et al. · Nature Nanotechnology 5, 722 (2010) cited by 7,165